| Most Touchdowns Scored |
| Game |
6, John Smith vs. Ks. Wesleyan 1984 |
|
6, Phil Regier vs. Sterling 1989 |
| Season |
18, Ed Smith 1984 |
| Career |
47, Ed Smith 1983-86 |
| Points Scored |
| Game |
36, John Smith vs. Ks. Wesleyan 1984 |
|
36, Phil Regier vs. Sterling 1989 |
| Season |
112, Ed Smith 1984 |
| Career |
286, Ed Smith 1983-86 |
| Passes Completed |
| Game |
29, Brent Martens vs. McPherson 1998 |
| Season |
158, Brent Martens 1997 |
| Career |
523, Brent Martens 1997-2000 |
| Passes Attempted |
| Game |
52, Victor Flores vs. University of Saint Mary 2004 |
| Season |
337, Brent Martens 1998 |
| Career |
1,118, Brent Martens 1997-2000 |
| Passing Percentage |
| Game |
(>15) 81.3% (13 of 16), Carlos Moral vs. Tabor 1987 |
| Season |
(>100) 60.6% (131 of 216), Brett Clow 2006 |
| Career |
(>250) 56.3% (480 of 852), Brett Clow 2005-2008 |
| Passing Yardage |
| Game |
459 yds, Victor Flores vs. University of Saint Mary 2004 |
| Season |
2,464 yds, Brett Clow, 2008 |
| Career |
6,584 yds, Brent Martens 1997-2000 |
| Touchdown Passes Thrown |
| Game |
6, Scott Stiles vs. Friends 1986 |
|
6, Carlos Moral vs. Sterling 1989 |
| Season |
26, Milen Zuzek 1984 |
| Career |
58, Milen Zuzek 1983-85 |
| Passes Caught |
| Game |
14, Ed Smith vs. Friends & Bethany 1985 |
| Season |
75, Ed Smith 1985 |
| Career |
200, Phil Regier 1987-90 |
| Yards Gained Receiving |
| Game |
284 yds, Ed Smith vs. Friends 1985 |
| Season |
1,232 yds, Ed Smith 1985 |
| Career |
3,337 yds, Ed Smith 1983-86 |
| Touchdown Passes Caught |
| Game |
6, Phil Regier vs. Sterling 1989 |
| Season |
18, Ed Smith 1984 |
| Career |
47, Ed Smith 1983-86 |
| Longest Completed Pass |
| Game |
95 yds, Scott Stiles to Ed Smith vs. Sterling 1986 |
| Point After Touchdowns |
| Game |
7, Michael Montez vs. Bethany College 2005 |
| Season |
33 (33 of 34), Michael Montez 2005 |
| Career |
109, Michael Montez 2004-2007 |
| PAT Kicking Percentage |
| Season |
(>10) 100% (10 of 10), Tony Graber 1970 |
|
100% (15 of 15), Nathan Hart 1982 |
|
100% (19 of 19), Jason Hershey 1994 |
| Career |
(>30) 90.8% (109 0f 120), Michael Montez, 2004-2007 |
| Pass Interceptions |
| Game |
3, Eric Peters vs. Tabor 1996 |
|
3, Rudy Rolle vs. Tabor 1993 |
|
3, Eric Rhoades vs. Ks. Wesleyan 1985 |
|
3, Michael Glenn vs. Ottawa 1983 |
|
3, Franklin Stucky vs. McPherson 1970 |
|
3, George Goering vs. Bethany 1955 |
| Season |
9, Brandon Kaufman 2007 |
|
9, Franklin Stucky 1970 |
| Career |
23, Brandon Kaufman 2004-2007 |
| Pass Interceptions by a Lineman |
| Game |
2, George Rogers III vs. McPherson 1967 |
| Longest Pass Interception Return |
| Game |
85 yds, George Goering vs. Bethany 1955 |
|
85 yds, Charlie Tubbs vs. Panhandle A&M 1935 |
| Longest Fumble Return |
| Game |
91 yds, John Tribuiano vs. SWAG 1999 |
| Unassisted Tackles |
| Game |
23, George Rogers, III vs. McPherson 1967 |
| Season |
109, Clarence Shuler 1986 |
| Career |
223, Clarence Shuler 1984-87 |
| Quarterback Sacks |
| Game |
5, Tod Bean vs. McPherson 1992 |
|
5, Derek Moses vs. St. Mary of the Plains 1978 |
| Season |
17, Alfredo Malcom 1996 |
| Career |
32, Alfredo Malcom 1994-96 |
| Fumble Recoveries |
| Game |
7, vs. Tabor 1995 |
|
7, vs. Ks. Wesleyan 1977 |
| Season |
27, 1996 |
| Rushing Attempts |
| Game |
45, Danny Castro vs. Bethany 1992 |
| Season |
299, Phillip Barron 2005 |
| Career |
776, Phillip Barron 2002-2005 |
| Yards Rushing |
| Game |
343 yds, Brent Martens vs. Ottawa 1999 |
| Season |
1,556 yds, Beau Cox 2006 |
| Career |
3,379 yds, Phillip Barron 2002-2005 |
| Longest Rush from Scrimmage |
| Game |
92 yds, George Goering vs. Baker 1954 |
| Rushing Touchdowns |
| Game |
6, John Smith vs. Ks. Wesleyan 1984 |
| Season |
16, Phillip Barron 2005 |
| Career |
31, Phillip Barron 2002-2005 |
| Total Offense |
| Game |
473 yds, Brent Martens vs. Ottawa 1999 |
| Season |
2,313 yds, Brent Martens 1999 |
| Career |
8,306 yds, Brent Martens 1997-2000 |
| Punting Average |
| Game |
(>4) 47 yds (7 for 330 yds), Brandon Carter vs. Southwestern 1996 |
| Season |
(>20) 42.9 yds (29 for 1245 yds), Garrett Whorton 2005 |
| Career |
(>100) 38.5 yds (194 for 7,472 yds), Wynn Goering 1972-75 |
| Longest Punt from Scrimmage |
| Game |
80 yds, Andrew Baeza vs. Ks. Wesleyan 2005 |
| Punt Return Average |
| Season |
(>10) 20.57 yds (14 for 288 yds), Peter Garibaldi 2003 |
| Career |
(>30) 15.6 yds (65 for 1012 yds), Peter Garibaldi 2002-2005 |
| Longest Punt Return |
| Game |
94 yds, Duane Murray vs. Baker 1967 |
| Kickoff Return Average |
| Season |
(>10) 30.5 yds (20 for 607 yds) Chad Hershberger 2005 |
| Career |
(>30) 27.29 yds (34 for 928 yds) Chad Hershberger 2005 |
| Longest Kickoff Return |
| Game |
95 yds, Chad Hershberger vs. Friends 2005 |
|
95 yds, James McCrae vs. St. Mary of the Plains 1973 |
| Field Goals |
| Game |
3, Wynn Goering vs. St. Mary of the Plains 1973 |
| Season |
12, Chris Rico 2000 |
| Career |
33, Michael Montez 2004-07 |
| Longest Field Goal |
| Game |
52 yds, Braden Dragomir vs. Southwestern, 2008 |
| Team Points Scored |
| Game |
54 vs. Tabor 2000 |
|
54 vs. Tabor 2008 |
| Season |
326, 1984 (10 games) |
| Most Points Allowed |
| Game |
114 vs. Baker 1922 |
| Season |
411, 2001 |
| Fewest Points Allowed |
| Season |
6, 1934 and 1941 |
| Yards Rushing |
| Game |
406 yds vs. Sterling 1941 |
| Season |
2,248 yds 1986 |
| Yards Passing |
| Game |
389 yds vs. Friends 1985 |
| Season |
2,221 yds 1997 |
| Total Yardage |
| Game |
629 yds vs. McPherson 1998 |
| Season |
3,872 yds 1984 (10 games) |
| Fewest Yards Allowed Passing |
| Game |
0 yds (0 for 5) vs. Ks. Wesleyan 2006 |
|
0 yds (0 for 11) vs. McPherson 1994 |
|
0 yds (0 for 9) vs. Tabor 1985 |
| Fewest Yards Allowed Rushing |
| Game |
-30 yds vs. Tabor 1999 |
| Season |
322 yds 2007 |
| Fewest Yards Gained Passing |
| Game |
1 yd (1 for 7) vs. Friends 1974 |
| Total Defense |
| Game |
14 yds vs. Friends 1962 |
| Season |
1,528 yds 1976 (9 games) |
| Pass Interceptions |
| Game |
6, vs. Ks. Wesleyan 1960 |
|
6, vs. Ottawa 1983 |
| Season |
22, 2007 |
| Quarterback Sacks |
| Season |
42, 1977 |